Fire Island Pines Vacation Rentals, Sayville: house rentals & more

Discover a selection of 54 homes and other vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines that are perfect for your trip. Whether you’re staying in a vacation home with friends, family, or even just your pets, you'll have the amenities you expect and more, which might include cable TV and a washer and dryer. Whatever you're looking for, you'll be able to choose a rental that has what everyone needs, including a place that is accessible or non-smoking.

Find spaces that suit your style

House

Condo/Apartment

Cabin

Cottage

Villa

Find the best place to stay - Fire Island Pines

Fire Island-pines-historic House-heated Pool AND HOT TUB

Sleeps 8 · 4 bedrooms · 2 bathrooms

Unique multi-level, private tree house w/pool, close to town,1 block to ocean.

Sleeps 6 · 3 bedrooms · 2 bathrooms

3BR/2.5bath Ocean View Home in Fire Island Pines with heated pool

Sleeps 6 · 3 bedrooms · 2+ bathrooms

Modern gem nestled in the Pines Community.

Sleeps 10 · 4 bedrooms · 2+ bathrooms

Mid-century modern escape steps from the ocean! Large Sunny Heated Pool, A/C

Sleeps 8 · 4 bedrooms · 3 bathrooms

Top rated rentals - Fire Island Pines

Fire pit and seating for a perfect night watching the stars

Premier Host

Charming perfect stay!

Relaxing weekend

Wonderful place and great host

Perfect for a group getaway on Fire Island Pines

Find out more about Fire Island Pines

Why visit Fire Island Pines

Beautiful Beaches: Relax on pristine shores with breathtaking views of high dunes, perfect for beach lovers.
Outdoor Activities: Engage in birdwatching and explore the natural beauty of nearby parks and scenic trails.
Charming Community: Experience vibrant neighborhoods and unique beach houses, fostering a welcoming atmosphere.
Cultural Experiences: Enjoy the blend of relaxation and adventure, ideal for both couples and families.
Variety of Accommodations: Choose from cozy cottages, private homes, and apartments tailored for a memorable stay.

Popular types of accommodation in Fire Island Pines

Explore an array of vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines, where you'll find charming private homes, inviting apartments, and cozy cottages. Many of these accommodations feature amenities like sauna decks and free WiFi, ensuring an unforgettable stay. Whether you choose the Capt's Cottage or another option, you'll enjoy a perfect getaway tailored to your needs.

Houses: A favored choice for travelers to Fire Island Pines, offering spacious and comfortable settings perfect for families, friends, or couples.
Apartments: A close second, these rentals provide a convenient and cozy atmosphere for those seeking a home-like experience.
Cottages: Third on the list, these charming spots offer a quaint and inviting retreat for a relaxing getaway.
Condos: Popular for their modern amenities, condos deliver a stylish and comfortable stay.
Villas: Rounding out the list, villas provide luxurious accommodations for an upscale vacation experience.**

Top attractions in Fire Island Pines

Fire Island Pines offers a delightful blend of outdoor activities, beach relaxation, and family-friendly experiences. Visitors can explore beautiful beaches, national and urban parks, and indulge in birdwatching amid the serene pines. This charming destination is perfect for those seeking cultural experiences and great adventures while enjoying the natural beauty of the area.

Ocean Beach: A picturesque beach located 5 miles from Fire Island Pines, Ocean Beach is known for its vibrant beach vibes, perfect for sunbathing, swimming, and enjoying the ocean breeze. It's a popular spot for both relaxation and socializing.
Carrington House: Situated within Fire Island Pines, Carrington House is a historic landmark that showcases rich cultural vibes. Visitors can explore its unique architecture and learn about its significance in the local community.
Stony Brook University: Located 18 miles away, Stony Brook University is a modern institution with city vibes. Its beautiful campus offers a range of cultural events and activities, making it a great place to experience academic life.

Things to do recommended for couples

Fire Island Pines offers unforgettable romantic experiences. Enjoy a playful round of mini golf at Bay Shore Mini Golf, savor exquisite wines at Harmony Vineyards, or get your adrenaline pumping with a tandem jump at Long Island Skydiving Center. Adventure and romance await you!

Things to do recommended for families

Your family will have a fantastic time at Lasorda Legacy Park, perfect for sports enthusiasts. Enjoy the adventure at Bowl Long Island, ideal for arcade fun, and unwind at Lakeland County Park, offering a serene atmosphere for relaxation and wellness.

Things to do recommended for groups

Experience the vibrant arts at the Patchogue Theatre for the Performing Arts, shop at the Tanger Outlets for the latest trends, or enjoy a round of golf at Stonebridge Golf Links and Country Club. Each offers unique fun for your group in and around Fire Island Pines.

What do I need to keep in mind when booking a vacation in Fire Island Pines

If you're traveling with a group, family, pets, or planning an extended stay, be sure to use the appropriate filters to meet your needs. Here are some helpful Vrbo booking tips to guide you.

Traveling to Fire Island Pines with a group: Take into account how many bedrooms you require, along with features like a complete kitchen or outdoor areas for group gatherings. Luckily, you can easily filter for these options and more on Vrbo.
Traveling to Fire Island Pines with young kids: Traveling with young kids can be quite a task. It's important to prioritize their comfort and safety, along with suitable amenities like a private swimming pool. Additionally, it's wise to think about how close you are to family-friendly attractions.
Taking your pets with you to Fire Island Pines: For many families, a vacation wouldn’t be the same without their beloved pets. If this resonates with you, consider exploring Vrbo properties that welcome pets. Many of these pet-friendly accommodations offer feeding bowls and beds, ensuring that all members of your family feel comfortable and at home.
Planning for a long term stay visiting Fire Island Pines: If you're seeking vacation rentals that offer great deals for stays of a month or more, you've come to the perfect spot. By using the appropriate filters, you can effortlessly discover and save on monthly rental options. Don't forget to include features like a parking space, a well-equipped kitchen, or a private pool in your search for the ideal getaway.

Where to stay in Fire Island Pines

Fire Island Pines offers a unique blend of relaxation and adventure, making it a perfect destination for beach lovers and families alike. Explore the charming beach houses and vibrant communities, or unwind on the pristine shores with breathtaking views of the high dunes. Whether you're seeking romance or a family-friendly atmosphere, you'll find a welcoming environment filled with friendly people, making your vacation truly memorable.

Ronkonkoma: Located approximately 10 miles from Fire Island Pines, Ronkonkoma is a vibrant city that offers a blend of outdoor activities and family-friendly experiences. Travelers can enjoy a diverse range of attractions, including local parks and a picturesque lake perfect for picnicking and relaxation. The city boasts modern educational institutions and shopping areas, making it an ideal stop for those looking to explore local culture and amenities. Outdoor enthusiasts can also find golf courses nearby, providing a great way to enjoy the beautiful Long Island landscape.
Cherry Grove: Just 1 mile away from Fire Island Pines, Cherry Grove is a charming and artistic community known for its welcoming atmosphere and romantic vibe. The area features a thriving arts scene, with a local theater and arts center offering various performances and events throughout the year. Families can enjoy relaxing days at the beach and exploring the nearby park, which provides recreational opportunities for all ages. With its stunning shoreline and lively community spirit, Cherry Grove is a must-visit destination for those seeking a blend of nature and culture.
Ocean Beach: Located 5 miles from Fire Island Pines, Ocean Beach is renowned for its beautiful beaches and scenic views. This picturesque city is perfect for beach lovers and outdoor enthusiasts, offering a range of recreational areas and shopping options. Visitors can enjoy the local family beach or engage in various water activities. The serene lake nearby adds to the tranquil environment, making it a great spot for relaxation and reflection. Ocean Beach invites you to unwind and soak in the natural beauty of Long Island.

Best time to go to Fire Island Pines

If you're planning a trip to Fire Island Pines, it's a good idea to check both the weather and property rates. The warmest month is July. Peak season runs from June to August, while off-peak times, like October to December tend to have fewer bookings and better deals.

Calendar Month	Temperature	Precipitation	Cloudiness	Occupancy	Pricing
January	34.5°F (1.4°C)	Light Rain	Mostly Sunny	Average	Moderately Low
February	35.4°F (1.9°C)	Light Rain	Mostly Sunny	Average	Moderately High
March	40.5°F (4.7°C)	Light Rain	Mostly Sunny	Average	Moderately Low
April	49.3°F (9.6°C)	Light Rain	Mostly Sunny	Average	Average
May	58.5°F (14.7°C)	Light Rain	Mostly Sunny	Average	Average
June	67.6°F (19.8°C)	Light Rain	Mostly Sunny	High	Average
July	75.4°F (24.1°C)	Light Rain	Mostly Sunny	High	Moderately High
August	75.0°F (23.9°C)	Light Rain	Mostly Sunny	High	Moderately High
September	69.3°F (20.7°C)	Light Rain	Mostly Sunny	Average	Average
October	59.9°F (15.5°C)	Light Rain	Mostly Sunny	Low	Average
November	49.1°F (9.5°C)	Light Rain	Mostly Sunny	Low	Average
December	41.4°F (5.2°C)	Light Rain	Mostly Sunny	Low	Moderately Low

Booking with Vrbo is simple

Are you hoping to save on your next adventure? Being open to adjusting your travel dates can help, as prices can vary significantly. Additionally, opting for a longer stay often leads to substantial savings. To discover the perfect Vrbo rental that fits your budget, take advantage of our filters to sort by price, location, and type of vacation rental.

Save more with One Key

Reserve an eligible Vrbo for your group getaway and earn OneKeyCash™ on your booking. Being the planner has its perks! When you join our travel rewards program, One Key, you'll gain access to exclusive member savings and have the opportunity to earn and use OneKeyCash™ on qualifying reservations. Sign up today and start enjoying your savings!

Vrbo Trips: Effortless planning

Vrbo's handy Trip Board feature allows you to easily plan new trips, pick up where you left off, or manage your travel arrangements in one convenient place. You can find the properties you've saved and booked organized under Potential, Upcoming, or Current Trips. To start using Trip Boards, simply visit: https://www.vrbo.com/trips.

**Based on Vrbo properties booked during 2023 and 2024.

Take in the waterfront beauty of Fire Island Pines

The island views and surrounding scenery provide a peaceful ambiance to your vacation home in Fire Island Pines. This city is well-known for its surfing and boating. If you need more space to accommodate a family vacation or friends trip, rental homes often come with separate dining areas and spacious living rooms.

Activities and attractions in and around Fire Island Pines

Are you hoping to discover top things to see and do during your stay? Venture out of your vacation home and experience everything that makes Fire Island Pines a fun place to get away. Here are some of the top attractions to explore, all within 30 miles (48.2 km) of the city center:

Town of Brookhaven Wildlife and Ecology Center (9.3 mi / 15 km)
Stonebridge Golf Links and Country Club (13.7 mi / 22 km)
Bowl Long Island at Patchogue (7.1 mi / 11.4 km)
Boomers! Medford (11.7 mi / 18.9 km)
Country Fair Entertainment Park (13 mi / 20.9 km)
Sky Zone (13.9 mi / 22.4 km)

Exploring the natural landscape of Fire Island Pines

Whether you're looking for fun outdoor activities or just want to appreciate the scenery, Fire Island Pines is a great place to get outside. These are a few of the area's most stunning sights, all within 30 miles (48.2 km) of the city center:

Sunken Forest (2.4 mi / 3.9 km)
Ocean Beach (4.7 mi / 7.5 km)
Shorefront Park (6.6 mi / 10.7 km)
Fire Island National Seashore (6.8 mi / 10.9 km)
Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park (7.4 mi / 11.9 km)
Robert Moses Beach (11.2 mi / 18.1 km)

Transportation to and around Fire Island Pines

The nearest airport is in MacArthur Airport (ISP), located 8.7 mi (14 km) from the city center. If you can't find a flight that works for your travel itinerary, you can also fly into Shirley, NY (WSH-Brookhaven Calabro), which is 15.1 mi (24.3 km) away.

Frequently asked questions

What is the most popular type of vacation rental accommodation in Fire Island Pines?

The most sought-after types of vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines are apartments. Hoping for something different? Vrbo offers a variety of options to match the unique needs of our guests, so you’ll see properties in all shapes and sizes, and for all budgets. The perfect fit is waiting for you — grab yours today.

How much does it cost to rent a vacation rental in Fire Island Pines?

A range of factors can influence the price of a vacation rental in Fire Island Pines, such as the type of property, season and length of stay. Still, all of our vacation homes have something in common — excellent value. Just enter your travel dates to find your perfect fit.

How much does it cost to rent a beach house in Fire Island Pines?

When you travel and the size and style of the property will help determine the cost of your beachside vacation rental. Click on your Fire Island Pines travel dates to view your available options on Vrbo. Looking for basics like WiFi, or perks like a private pool? Use the filters to select the amenities and features you need.

Are there pet-friendly vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines?

Yes. You can choose from 43 vacation rentals that welcome pets in Fire Island Pines on Vrbo. Our furry companions need to get away from it all too, so simply use our search function for pet-friendly vacation rentals to book a property where Fido can lap up the good times.

Can I rent a house with a pool in Fire Island Pines?

Check the “pool” box in our filter tool and pick from 35 houses with private pools in Fire Island Pines on Vrbo. Morning swim, afternoon splash or midnight soak? How you spend your leisure time is up to you when your vacation property comes with its own pool.

What are popular rental amenities in Fire Island Pines?

When it comes to rental amenities that guests are looking for in Fire Island Pines, an ocean view, a chef and a lake view rank the highest. With Vrbo vacation rentals, you’ll enjoy choices to match your style and taste, whether you’re on a trip with relatives, friends or even pets.

Are there large group vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines?

You can choose from four vacation homes in Fire Island Pines that can host 10 or more people. Whether you’re planning a trip with the family or an event like a birthday party, there’s plenty of room to get your favorite people together under one roof.

Are there vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines that welcome kids?

With 43 family-friendly vacation rentals to select from in Fire Island Pines, there’s never been a better time to introduce your little ones to the thrills of travel. Simply click on our “Properties good for families” filter to search for stays that feature amenities perfect for families on the move, such as extra bedrooms, pools, entertainment areas and hot tubs.

What are the top attractions for families in Fire Island Pines?

Spend a fun day out with the family at Carrington House. This awesome attraction is near the heart of Fire Island Pines.

Can I find two-bedroom vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines?

Choose from five two-bedroom homes in Fire Island Pines. Put the kids in the second room or maybe fill it with a couple of your best buddies. There’s space for whoever’s lucky enough to be coming along.

Are there vacation rentals with WiFi in Fire Island Pines?

You can pick from 25 vacation rentals with WiFi in Fire Island Pines. If you want to disconnect from daily life during your trip, but still need to be connected to the internet, these properties have just what you need. Narrow your search by applying the WiFi filter on Vrbo.

How can I find vacation rentals with air conditioning in Fire Island Pines?

Pick your travel dates and then make use of our filters to look for vacation rentals with air conditioning in Fire Island Pines on Vrbo. With 38 air-conditioned properties on offer here, you can enjoy a cool and comfy stay.

How old do you have to be to rent a vacation rental in Fire Island Pines?

You should check with the Fire Island Pines vacation home you want on Vrbo as the minimum age differs. However, it’s generally 16, 18 or 21.

How long can I rent a vacation rental in Fire Island Pines for?

It all depends on the Fire Island Pines property. To see all available options offering extended stays, simply enter your travel dates and number of people into Vrbo. You can look forward to having the property to yourself, as well as amenities such as a full kitchen, air conditioning and an outdoor space where the kids can burn off energy. Keep an eye out for long-term stays that offer discounted weekly or monthly prices.

Does Vrbo offer discounts for vacation homes in Fire Island Pines?

Short break or a much-needed extended escape, Vrbo has some incredible bargains and discounts in Fire Island Pines to match your style and budget. Browse our weekly and monthly discounts on vacation rentals, or see what’s recently been added with one of our newly listed homes. Whatever kind of getaway you’re after, you’ll find the perfect place to stay — at an affordable rate.

Rental Ideas

You can now earn and use rewards on eligible Vacation rentals.